Teaching Order of Operations: Why PEMDAS Isn’t the Whole Story

Math Teaching Guide

Teaching Order of Operations: Why PEMDAS Isn’t the Whole Story

Why PEMDAS alone leads to the most common student mistake, the left-to-right rule that fixes it, and a 4-day mini-unit that pairs with the printable lesson.

Teaching Resources › Math Teaching Guides › Teaching Order of Operations: Why PEMDAS Isn’t the Whole Story

A grade 5-7 student working through a multi-step math problem in a notebook with a pencil, pausing to think.
PEMDAS sticks; the left-to-right rule inside it does not. The fix starts with how the order is shown, not with more drill.

Ask a class of fifth graders “what does PEMDAS mean?” and you’ll get the right answer almost every time. Ask the same students to evaluate 20 ÷ 4 × 5 and a worrying number will say 1 instead of 25. They followed PEMDAS exactly — that’s the problem. The mnemonic implies a strict six-step march, but two pairs of operations are actually evaluated left to right. This guide unpacks the most common order-of-operations mistake, explains the rule that fixes it, and offers a 4-day mini-unit that pairs with the printable Order of Operations Lesson.

Order of operations is best taught right after multi-digit multiplication and division are fluent — the same window where you’d teach long division. If students are still hesitant about basic computation, layered expressions will overwhelm working memory before the order rules even come into play.

What PEMDAS Actually Means (and Doesn’t)

PEMDAS stands for Parentheses, Exponents, Multiplication, Division, Addition, Subtraction. The trouble is the order of those last four letters suggests M comes before D and A comes before S. It doesn’t. The accurate version is:

A vertical four-tier diagram of the order of operations: Parentheses, Exponents, Multiply / Divide (left to right), Add / Subtract (left to right).
The order of operations as a four-tier hierarchy. The paired tiers are worked left to right, not strictly in PEMDAS letter order.
  1. Parentheses first.
  2. Exponents next.
  3. Multiplication and Division — whichever comes first, left to right.
  4. Addition and Subtraction — whichever comes first, left to right.

Multiplication and division are the same priority — they’re inverse operations. Same for addition and subtraction. The mnemonic was built for memorability, not accuracy, and that gap is exactly where the most common student mistake lives.

The Mistake That Costs the Most Points

Here is the worked example that catches almost every class:

Evaluate: 20 ÷ 4 × 5

The PEMDAS-strict (wrong) approach: Multiplication comes before Division in PEMDAS, so do 4 × 5 = 20 first, then 20 ÷ 20 = 1.

The correct (left-to-right) approach: M and D are the same priority, so work left to right. 20 ÷ 4 = 5, then 5 × 5 = 25.

The same trap exists with addition and subtraction. 10 − 3 + 2 evaluates to 9, not 5. A student who treats 3 + 2 as a unit because A comes before S in PEMDAS will get the wrong answer every time.

This is not a rare edge case. It’s in standardized tests, in textbooks, and in real-world calculations. The reframe matters.

How to Reteach the Rule So It Sticks

Replacing PEMDAS with a more accurate version is more durable than asking students to memorize an exception:

Stack the levels

Draw the rule as four levels on the board, with M/D on the same row and A/S on the same row:

  • Level 1: Parentheses
  • Level 2: Exponents
  • Level 3: Multiplication / Division — left to right
  • Level 4: Addition / Subtraction — left to right

Adding the “left to right” tag at levels 3 and 4 gives students something to point to when they’re uncertain. Some teachers use GEMS (Groupings, Exponents, Multiplication/division, Subtraction/addition) instead — the lowercase pair makes the same priority visually obvious.

Show the rewrite

When students hit a level-3 or level-4 expression, have them rewrite the expression before evaluating, replacing each step with its result and bringing down the rest:

  • 20 ÷ 4 × 5
  • = 5 × 5
  • = 25

Rewriting forces left-to-right processing and shows their work in a way you can follow when checking. Mental calculation is where students skip steps and lose the order.

The Five Most Common Student Mistakes

1. Treating M and D as strictly ordered

Looks like: 20 ÷ 4 × 5 = 1. Why: PEMDAS implies M before D. Fix: The level-3 reframe above. Read M/D as a single level, work left to right.

2. Treating A and S as strictly ordered

Looks like: 10 − 3 + 2 = 5. Why: Same reason as #1, applied to addition and subtraction. Fix: Same fix — A and S share level 4, work left to right.

3. Skipping parentheses

Looks like: 2 × (3 + 4) = 6 + 4 = 10 instead of 2 × 7 = 14. Why: Students apply the multiplication first because the × sign is visible and the parentheses look optional. Fix: Box every set of parentheses before starting the problem. The visual highlight changes behavior.

4. Forgetting that the negative sign in front belongs to the number

Looks like: −32 evaluated as 9 when the expression actually means −(32) = −9. Why: The exponent applies only to 3, not to −3, unless parentheses say so. Fix: Direct contrast. Write −32 and (−3)2 next to each other and walk through both.

5. Computing inside parentheses but in the wrong order

Looks like: (8 − 4 ÷ 2) evaluated left to right as (4 ÷ 2) = 2, when the order rules apply inside parentheses too. Fix: Inside parentheses, the same four-level rule still applies. Treat each parenthesis group as its own mini-problem.

A Suggested 4-Day Mini-Unit

A focused four-day sequence is enough to lock in the rules and the most common error patterns. The printable Order of Operations Lesson covers the same arc, including a 4-mistake error-check section that mirrors the traps below.

  • Day 1 — The four levels. Introduce the level chart. Practice 8–10 simple expressions with only one operation type per problem to build confidence in the framework.
  • Day 2 — The left-to-right pair rule. Direct instruction on M/D and A/S sharing priority. Worked examples (the 20÷4×5 family). Practice expressions that specifically test left-to-right.
  • Day 3 — Mixed expressions and error analysis. Use the printable lesson’s error-check page. Students identify what went wrong in worked-out problems and rewrite them correctly. Diagnostic gold.
  • Day 4 — Word problems and assessment. Apply order of operations to one-step word problems and an end-of-unit check. Hold a brief whole-class debrief on the most-missed item.

After the unit, run 2-3 mixed expressions as warm-ups for the next two weeks. Spaced practice is what makes the rule durable past the unit test.

Open the Order of Operations Lesson

Multi-page printable lesson with the four-level reference, worked examples for the left-to-right pair, mixed practice, an error-check section that targets the four most common mistakes, and a complete answer key.

Classroom Printable

Order of Operations Anchor Chart

A printable PEMDAS anchor chart for your math wall — a steady reference as students learn the order of operations.

Get the anchor chart →

Looking for grade-level practice? Browse worksheets by grade: Grade 5 · Grade 6 · Grade 7

Looking for more math teaching guides? Browse Math Teaching Guides →